9 Consignment Shops for Selling Stuff Online and In Person

Are you searching for places to sell your old stuff? Here are nine consignment shops worth exploring!

Are you looking for a way to get rid of some of your unwanted stuff and make some extra money? While having a garage sale may be a reasonable idea, you can’t really influence who chooses to stop by your home, and they may not be interested in the items you have. 

The best solution is to consider selling your stuff at consignment shops that actually have a demand for your specific items. Many consignment shops buy and sell a wide range of products, including clothes, accessories, furniture, and even electronics. 

If you’re wondering where to start, here are some of the best consignment shops for selling stuff online and in person. 

1. thredUP

thredUP is an online consignment shop for women’s and kids’ clothing, shoes, and accessories. To sell items, you’ll need to create an account and order a “Clean Out Kit” bag ($2.99), or you can print out a prepaid label and use your own box to ship your clothing to them.

thredUP performs a 12-point inspection to ensure the clothing meets its quality standards. Then they photograph and list the items for sale on their website. Once your items sell, you’ll earn a percentage (3%-80%) of the sale price. The site offers a payout calculator to show you how much you could make. 

For using their service, thredUP deducts a $14.99 service fee from your earnings. To get an idea of what you can earn using this consignment shop, check out Holly’s thredUP review, where she chronicles her experience using the platform. 

2. Poshmark

Poshmark is a popular online platform for selling gently-used clothing and accessories. The site offers a simple process to list and sell your items. You can create your listing by uploading photos of your item(s). Poshmark also allows you to set your own pricing and share your listing with other followers to help shoppers find your items. 

When an item sells, Poshmark provides a prepaid label to ship the item to the customer. Then, you’ll receive payment as soon as the order is complete. Poshmark takes a 20% commission on sales of $15 or more and a flat rate of $2.95 for sales under $15. Poshmark is ideal for selling trendy, high-end, or vintage items.

3. The RealReal

If you’re looking to sell high-end items such as designer clothing, bags, and jewelry, The RealReal is a great option. The Real Real is an online consignment store that focuses on luxury items from designer brands such as Cartier, Kate Spade, Gucci, Tiffany, Prada, Chanel, and Tory Burch.

To start selling your items, you’ll need to create an account, list your items, and send them to the company for an authenticity check and photography. The Real Real is picky about the items they accept, but the payoff can be substantial.

4. Vestiaire Collective (Tradesy)

Vestiaire Collective, formerly known as Tradesy, is an online consignment shop that resells luxury brands and designer items for men’s and women’s clothing, children’s clothing, and accessories like bags and jewelry. You can find brands like Christian Louboutin, Hermès, Burberry, Chanel, and Coach here. 

The Vestiaire Collective has low fees and free payouts, and they help you sell your items faster by finding targeted buyers for you. To start selling your items, sign up for the platform and create a listing for your item with images. You’ll receive a free and insured prepaid label to ship your item when it sells. Sellers earn up to 85% of the list price. 

5. Plato’s Closet

Plato’s Closet is a popular chain of consignment stores that specialize in gently-used clothing. You will need to see if there’s a Plato’s Closet store near you. If there is, you can take your clothing to the store, and they will offer you cash on the spot. Plato’s Closet may not accept all your items, and each store has its own quality requirements, but it’s an easy way to make money on clothing you’re no longer wearing. 

The store focuses on trendy items popular with teens and young adults. To make the most of Plato’s Closet, you need to follow their guidelines, such as bringing in clothing that is in style and season-appropriate. For example, if you live in an area with harsh winters, you may not want to bring all your shorts and tank tops in for consideration. Instead, the best time to bring those items in would be early spring, so the store has a better chance of reselling them quickly. 

6. Facebook Marketplace

If you’re looking to sell your items locally, Facebook Marketplace is a solid option for buying and selling things in your local community. Facebook Marketplace is great for selling bulky or large items like furniture, bikes, toys, home decor, and electronics. 

You can list your items for free, set your own prices, and arrange a meet-up with the buyer. You can message buyers through the Facebook app to share additional details and negotiate pricing. However, if you wish to sell your items as soon as possible, it’s best to write a specific listing description, including the color, brand, and dimensions. If you don’t want to disclose your address, you can always meet the buyer in a public location.

7. Chairish 

Chairish is an online consignment store that allows you to sell your vintage furniture, antiques, and well-maintained home décor. The site is set up so that you can easily upload your images, and you can keep up to 70% of your sale price after the 48-hour return window. You can opt for payment through PayPal or credit. 

Chairish is very particular about the items accepted and will carefully review your listing to ensure it meets its standards. The company also organizes shipping details for you, or you can arrange local pickup and delivery with buyers. You also can expand your customer base by offering discounts to interior designers. 

8. Crossroads Trading

Crossroads Trading is a brick-and-mortar consignment shop that buys and sells clothing and accessories. This store is an excellent choice for selling a variety of items, from designer purses to well-maintained vintage styles. 

To sell your items, you can make an appointment to bring things in, and the Crossroads Trading team will review your haul to see if they want to buy anything. If your items are approved, you can choose from payment through PayPal or store credit. Or, you can donate your earnings. 

For trades or in-store credit, you’ll receive 50% of the price your items will sell for in the store. However, if you opt to receive cash for your items, Crossroads Trading only pays 30% of what they will price your items to sell in the store.

9. Buffalo Exchange

Buffalo Exchange is a nationwide brick-and-mortar thrift store where you can buy, sell, and trade your old clothing. Just stop by one of their many locations; no appointment is needed. They’ll give you 25% of their selling price in cash or 50% in-store credit. Buffalo Exchanges accepts both current men’s and women’s clothing that’s in good shape and vintage items. You will need a valid ID to sell your clothing. 

Final Thoughts on Using Consignment Shops

There are so many ways to consign items that are just sitting around your home or in storage. Whether you choose an in-person or online consignment store, making some extra money from your items is very simple. 

Consider which consignment shops may be the best choice for what you’re looking to sell, and realize you don’t need to have high-end brands to make money. Also, be sure to check the consignment shop’s guidelines and seasonal needs so you can increase your chances of selling your stuff quickly.

Do you know of other consignment shops to use for selling stuff? Drop us a note; we’d love to hear from you!